It can be both rewarding and stressful to manage an investment portfolio. Many investors start by buying individual stocks because they are drawn to the possibility of higher returns and the thrill of learning about companies. But over time, keeping track of performance, rebalancing, and managing risk can become a lot of work. All-in-one Exchange-Traded Funds are becoming more and more popular because they are designed to give investors a wide range of options, make managing their money easier, and save them money. These funds put stocks, bonds, and sometimes global exposure into one package. They are popular with investors who want things to be simple but still want to keep their balance. But is it a good idea to switch from a portfolio of stocks to an all-in-one ETF? The choice depends on things like how much risk you’re willing to take, your investment goals, the tax consequences, and whether you prefer to manage things yourself. We’ll look at the pros and cons to help investors decide if it makes sense to combine into an all-in-one ETF in 2025.
What is an All-in-One ETF?
An all-in-one ETF is a diversified fund that holds a mix of stocks, bonds, and sometimes alternative assets in a single product. These funds automatically rebalance to maintain a target asset allocation, making them a convenient choice for investors who want a “set-it-and-forget-it” approach.
Important Features of All-in-One ETFs
- Diversification: Exposure to multiple asset classes and geographic regions.
- Automatic Rebalancing: Maintains target allocation without manual intervention.
- Cost Efficiency: Lower management expense ratios (MERs) compared to mutual funds.
- Accessibility: Traded like stocks on major exchanges, with transparent holdings.
Pros of Switching to an All-in-One ETF
| Benefit | Why It Matters |
|---|---|
| Diversification | Reduces concentration risk by spreading across sectors and markets. |
| Lower Costs | Most ETFs charge significantly lower fees than actively managed funds. |
| Tax Efficiency | ETFs typically generate fewer capital gains distributions than mutual funds. |
| Ease of Trading | Can be bought and sold during market hours like individual stocks. |
| Transparency | Holdings are usually disclosed daily, offering clarity on portfolio exposure. |
Cons of Selling Stocks for an All-in-One ETF
| Drawback | Consideration |
|---|---|
| Capital Gains Taxes | Selling existing stocks may trigger taxable events. |
| Missed Potential | Individual stocks may outperform ETFs, especially in growth sectors. |
| Lack of Customization | Asset allocation is fixed; investors cannot overweight preferred sectors. |
| Emotional Adjustment | Those who enjoy researching and selecting stocks may find ETFs less engaging. |
When Does It Make Sense to Switch?
- Portfolio Overload: If tracking multiple individual stocks feels unmanageable, an ETF can simplify.
- Life Transitions: Major events such as career changes, retirement planning, or family expansion often demand a more streamlined investment strategy.
- Market Uncertainty: For those uneasy about volatility, ETFs may provide stability through diversification.
- Shift in Goals: Moving from aggressive growth to balanced, long-term wealth preservation can make an ETF attractive.
What to Look for in an All-in-One ETF
Before consolidating into an ETF, it is important to evaluate:
- Performance History: Consistency in various market conditions.
- Expense Ratio (MER): Lower costs enhance net returns.
- Asset Allocation: Ensure the equity/bond mix aligns with long-term goals and risk tolerance.
- Geographic Exposure: Some ETFs lean heavily toward North America, while others offer global diversification.
- Liquidity: Higher trading volumes typically result in narrower bid-ask spreads.
ETFs vs. Individual Stocks
| Factor | Individual Stocks | All-in-One ETF |
|---|---|---|
| Control | Full control over selection and weighting | No control; allocation is predetermined. |
| Potential Returns | Can outperform if top stocks are chosen | Average returns across market exposure |
| Risk | Higher risk if concentrated in few companies | Lower risk due to broad diversification |
| Time Commitment | Requires ongoing research and rebalancing | Minimal oversight once invested |
| Costs | Trading fees, but no fund-level MER | Low MER, but ongoing fund expenses apply |
Conclusion
It all depends on how you think about investing and what your financial goals are if you should sell individual stocks and buy an all-in-one ETF. People who want something simple, balanced, and easy to manage may want to look into all-in-one ETFs for the long term. They are a good choice for investors who want to stay involved in the markets without having to do much. But if you like picking stocks, have portfolios that are good for taxes, or want to focus on certain stocks, it might still be worth it to keep individual holdings. A hybrid strategy, which mixes a core ETF with a few individual stocks, often gives you both stability and the chance to make more money. As the stock market changes, all-in-one ETFs become more and more popular. The best thing to do is to invest in things that match your goals, how much risk you’re willing to take, and how you want to live.
Frequently Asked Questions
What exactly is an all-in-one ETF?
It is a single investment fund that puts stocks, bonds, and sometimes other assets together into a diversified portfolio that is meant to automatically rebalance.
Why do some investors switch from stocks to ETFs?
ETFs make it less necessary to keep an eye on the market all the time and offer diversification, lower costs, and emotional relief from market volatility.
What are the risks of selling stocks to move into ETFs?
Some possible downsides are capital gains taxes, not being able to pick individual stocks that do better, and less customization.
Do ETFs always perform better than individual stocks?
No. ETFs usually do about as well as the market as a whole. However, stocks that you pick carefully can do better, but they also come with more risk.
How are all-in-one ETFs taxed in Canada and the U.S.?
Dividends, interest income, and capital gains distributions are all subject to taxes. If you sell stocks you already own to buy an ETF, you may have to pay taxes on the profits.
Can all-in-one ETFs be used for retirement investing?
Yes. They are popular for retirement accounts because they automatically balance risk and growth, which means you don’t have to do it by hand.
What are some popular all-in-one ETFs in 2025?
Vanguard’s All-in-One ETFs (VGRO, VBAL), iShares Core Portfolios (XEQT, XBAL), and BMO Balanced ETFs are some examples. Availability changes from one area to another.
Is it possible to combine ETFs and stocks in one portfolio?
Yes. A lot of investors have a core all-in-one ETF to spread out their investments and keep individual stocks for targeted growth.
Updated by Albert Fang
Source Citation References:
+ Inspo
There are no additional citations or references to note for this article at this time.